$22 Car Rental Shelter Island, NY

Search and Compare from Car Companies in Shelter Island

Photo by Brian V. Rowe
I have a discount code

Featured car rental suppliers

Compare from agencies

car suppliers logo

Change your mind: penalty-free cancellation on many/select car rentals

Treat yourself: One Key members save 10% or more on over 1 million car rentals

Shop Smart: Compare car suppliers and package your flight, hotel, and car to save

Top Car Deals in Shelter Island

* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices.

Wed, Sep 10 to Thu, Sep 11

Special

Manager Special EV or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Riverhead, New York, USA
Manager Special EV

$22

includes taxes & fees
$22 per day
found 14 hours ago
Special Manager Special EV
Wed, Sep 10 to Thu, Sep 11

Midsize SUV

Chevrolet Bolt EUV or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Riverhead, New York, USA
Chevrolet Bolt EUV

$22

includes taxes & fees
$22 per day
found 14 hours ago
Midsize SUV Chevrolet Bolt EUV
Wed, Sep 10 to Thu, Sep 11

Economy Special

Managers Special or similar
  • 4 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Riverhead, New York, USA
Managers Special

$29

includes taxes & fees
$29 per day
found 14 hours ago
Economy Special Managers Special
Tue, Sep 9 to Wed, Sep 10

Compact

Ford Focus or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Ford Focus

$30

includes taxes & fees
$30 per day
found 21 hours ago
Compact Ford Focus
Thu, Sep 11 to Fri, Sep 12

Fullsize

Chevrolet Malibu or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Groton, Connecticut, USA
Chevrolet Malibu

$34

includes taxes & fees
$34 per day
found 6 hours ago
Fullsize Chevrolet Malibu
Tue, Sep 9 to Wed, Sep 10

Midsize Elite

Tesla Short Range Model 3 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Tesla Short Range Model 3

$49

includes taxes & fees
$34 per day
found 17 hours ago
Midsize Elite Tesla Short Range Model 3
Tue, Sep 9 to Wed, Sep 10

Standard Elite Special

Ford Mustang Mach-E or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Ford Mustang Mach-E

$49

includes taxes & fees
$34 per day
found 17 hours ago
Standard Elite Special Ford Mustang Mach-E
Wed, Sep 10 to Thu, Sep 11

Premium

Nissan Maxima or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Riverhead, New York, USA
Nissan Maxima

$38

includes taxes & fees
$38 per day
found 14 hours ago
Premium Nissan Maxima
Wed, Sep 10 to Thu, Sep 11

Standard SUV

Chevrolet Equinox or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Riverhead, New York, USA
Chevrolet Equinox

$40

includes taxes & fees
$40 per day
found 14 hours ago
Standard SUV Chevrolet Equinox
Thu, Sep 11 to Fri, Sep 12

Fullsize Elite Pickup Regular Cab

Ram 2500 Big Horn or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Groton, Connecticut, USA
Ram 2500 Big Horn

$50

includes taxes & fees
$44 per day
found 6 hours ago
Fullsize Elite Pickup Regular Cab Ram 2500 Big Horn
Wed, Sep 10 to Thu, Sep 11

Mini Van

Chrysler Pacifica or similar
  • 7 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Riverhead, New York, USA
Chrysler Pacifica

$60

includes taxes & fees
$50 per day
found 14 hours ago
Mini Van Chrysler Pacifica
Mon, Sep 8 to Tue, Sep 9

Luxury

Chrysler 300 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Riverhead, New York, USA
Chrysler 300

$70

includes taxes & fees
$58 per day
found 14 hours ago
Luxury Chrysler 300
Wed, Sep 10 to Thu, Sep 11

Premium Elite SUV

Audi Q5 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Southampton, New York, USA
Audi Q5

$85

includes taxes & fees
$70 per day
found 14 hours ago
Premium Elite SUV Audi Q5
Tue, Sep 9 to Wed, Sep 10

Luxury Elite

Genesis G80E or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Genesis G80E

$114

includes taxes & fees
$82 per day
found 17 hours ago
Luxury Elite Genesis G80E
Wed, Sep 10 to Thu, Sep 11

Oversize SUV

Lincoln Navigator L Jeep Grand Wagoneer L or similar
  • 7 people
  • 100 free miles/total
Southampton, New York, USA
Lincoln Navigator L Jeep Grand Wagoneer L

$121

includes taxes & fees
$100 per day
found 14 hours ago
Oversize SUV Lincoln Navigator L Jeep Grand Wagoneer L
Tue, Sep 9 to Wed, Sep 10

Compact Elite Crossover

Volvo XC40 Hybrid or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Volvo XC40 Hybrid

$239

includes taxes & fees
$239 per day
found 17 hours ago
Compact Elite Crossover Volvo XC40 Hybrid

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car rentals in Shelter Island
View all cars
Lowest prices found within the past 14 hours. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Frequently asked questions

How much is a rental car per day in Shelter Island?
Follow your own road in Shelter Island, with car rental prices starting at just $22 a day. That's based on prices found within the past seven days. With rates like this, it'll be a piece of cake to find a ride that meets your needs.
Can I rent a car from New London, CT (GON-Groton - New London)?
Arrive at New London, CT (GON-Groton - New London) and then head to Budget or Avis, a short commute away. You'll be exploring Shelter Island in your own set of wheels in next to no time.
What happens if I need to cancel my Shelter Island car reservation?
We appreciate that flexibility while traveling is important. That's why many prepaid rentals give a full refund if you cancel a minimum of six hours prior to picking up the car. You may want to check the agreement though because there are some exceptions. If the information isn't there, click on our Customer Service Portal.
Where can I go on a road trip from Shelter Island?
There are so many adventures to be had in Shelter Island, but venture farther afield and you'll find even more magic. Rent a set of wheels and you can meander around the surrounding area at your own pace. Add these awesome places to your travel plan:

  • Head off to Providence for an excellent sightseeing adventure. Around 70 miles from Shelter Island, it has lots of great sights like Roger Williams Park Zoo.
  • Why not enjoy all that's on offer in Hartford too? Notable sights in this colorful city include Mark Twain House & Museum. Hartford is roughly 50 miles from Shelter Island.
  • Make your way to Longwood Gardens to discover some local nature. Pack a picnic to enjoy or just relax in the fresh air. From Shelter Island, it's 190 miles away.

How do I find the best car rental deals in Shelter Island with Expedia?
Pick up an incredible deal with Expedia. Just choose the car class, select your dates and preferred pickup and drop-off points, and compare offers from all the big-name brands. Save even more when you combine your Shelter Island car rental with hotel or flight bookings.
How old do you have to be to rent a car in Shelter Island?
You'll need to be 21 and over to hop behind the wheel of a rental car in Shelter Island. Keep in mind that young drivers may only be able to rent from a few car classes, such as economy and compact. Higher age limits usually apply for luxury and specialty vehicles. Many providers will also charge a fee for young renters. Check the rules before clicking book and factor any extra fees into your budget.
What do you need to rent a car in Shelter Island?
You'll generally require a current driver's license and credit card in your name when picking up your vehicle. Proof of coverage may also be required if you'd like to opt out of the company's insurance plan. Rules may differ between rental providers, so it's wise to read the fine print.
What is the cheapest car rental in Shelter Island?
Shelter Island has no doubt had some very happy car renters lately. Daily rates within the past seven days dropped as low as $22 and $29. These rates were available on Expedia, with a rental starting date within the next year. Prices and availability are subject to change and additional terms apply.
Can I rent a car for a month or longer in Shelter Island?
Yes, and the wonderful news is providers often offer lower rates the longer you rent. Look up our long-term car rental deals in Shelter Island and cruise off with an unbeatable bargain.
Where can I find a Shelter Island car rental if I am younger than 25?
Some Shelter Island providers will rent cars to drivers under 25, and others won't. Age policies differ between suppliers, so you should do some research. Also, find out if there are any extra costs. Some outlets will apply a surcharge to customers between 21 and 24. Always read through the terms and conditions so you know what to expect.
What insurance should I choose for my car rental in Shelter Island?
We recommend purchasing collision protection while reserving your Shelter Island rental car with Expedia. This protects your vehicle against collision damage, theft and vandalism throughout your road trip. Offering up to $35,000 in primary coverage and 24-hour emergency support, you can rest easy knowing you'll be covered if the unexpected happens. Simply opt in to this plan while reserving your rental vehicle.

Car Rental Information

 
Popular car types
SUV, Full Size, Economy
 
Car suppliers available
 
Our best deal of the day
$22
 
Our second best deal of the day
$29
 
Our third best deal of the day
$30
 
From the airport to your hotel
Airport Transportation
 
From popular domestic and international airports
Airport Car Rentals

Finding the cheapest car rentals in Shelter Island

Using our Search Wizard

If the deals that are available on our page do not suit your needs, then enter Shelter Island into the search wizard at the top of the page. We will compare all the best deals available for your car rental in Shelter Island and provide you with a list of the cheapest options, with no added fees.

Renting a car in Shelter Island

Pay at pickup is available, so you don’t have to worry about spending your money until you arrive at your vehicle in Shelter Island. We partner with reliable partners that guarantee an enjoyable experience for solo travelers, couples, and families. Package your car with a flight or hotel to unlock even more savings from Expedia.

Expected prices in Shelter Island

Prices are subject to seasonal change depending on when you decide to arrange your car rental but right now you can book from $22.

Flexibility & Cancellation

Most car suppliers offer penalty-free cancellations, so you don’t have to worry about losing money if your plans change. To cancel your booking log into your account through the Trips portal. Click manage booking and cancel this car. If you needed to alter your booking, then you can create a new one once you have canceled.

We all love being rewarded

One Key members save 10% or more on select hotels, cars, activities and vacation rentals. Not only that, earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands: Expedia, Hotels.com and VRBO. Learn more and join today.

Car classes available from Expedia in 2025

The classes of vehicles available will change depending on your chosen location.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Explore a world of travel with Expedia